Shortlisting DocuSign alternatives with a method, not a hunch.

Businesses look beyond DocuSign for many reasons: a renewal coming up, a change in how the team works, or simply wanting to check they have the right fit. The common names include Adobe Acrobat Sign, Dropbox Sign, PandaDoc, Zoho Sign and SignAndGo. This page sets out a way to shortlist and test them that a small office or a larger firm can follow in a few weeks.

Write down why you are looking

Before opening a single website, write one paragraph explaining what is not working today. Perhaps signers struggle on phones, approvals are skipped, the signed records are hard to find, or the tool does far more than you need. That paragraph becomes the test every alternative must pass. Without it, shortlists drift towards whichever tool had the most persuasive demonstration.

Split requirements into must, should and could

List what you need under three headings. Keep the must list short, because every item on it can eliminate a tool.

  • Must: signers need no account; a fixed signing order; a certificate on the signed PDF; your documents exportable at any time.
  • Should: templates from your own documents; automatic reminders; approvals enforced by the system; connection to your accounting software.
  • Could: bulk sending; upload fields so signers can attach a file; connectors for AI assistants; an API for your developer.

For every provider, confirm each item against their current plans rather than a comparison table. Tables, including any we publish, go out of date.

A simple scoring sheet

Give each shortlisted tool a column and each requirement a row. Score must items as pass or fail, and the rest from one to three. Add three rows that features cannot capture: how a first-time signer coped, how long a new staff member took to send an envelope, and how clear the finished record was. Ask two people to score independently, then compare. Where they disagree, run the test again.

Where SignAndGo fits

SignAndGo is a signing tool within MyAndGo. It accepts PDF and Word documents, offers drawn, typed or uploaded signatures plus initials, date, name, text, checkbox and conditional fields, runs sequential or simultaneous signing with approvers and CC recipients, and chases with automatic reminders. Every signed PDF carries an audit certificate and a verification ID that anyone can check on the public verify page. It also offers in-person and witness signing, acknowledgement-only envelopes, bulk send and very large documents. Score it against your sheet the same way as the others.

Run every tool through the same script

  1. Send your three most common documents, with colleagues as signers, in the order you use in real life.
  2. Make one signer use a phone and one use a work laptop behind your firewall.
  3. Change a signer after sending, and send a corrected version of one document.
  4. Download every signed copy and certificate, and file them as you would for real.

Five shortlisting traps

  1. Choosing on a recommendation from a business that sends completely different documents from yours.
  2. Letting the must list grow until no tool can pass it, then quietly ignoring half of it.
  3. Trialling with internal staff only, so nobody tests how an outside client copes on an old phone.
  4. Scoring features you will never switch on, such as bulk sending for a firm that sends one contract a week.
  5. Leaving the person who files and retrieves signed documents out of the decision altogether.

Give the signers a vote

The people who sign your documents are rarely the people who choose the tool, yet they decide whether a document comes back today or next week. Before you finish scoring, ask two or three friendly outsiders to sign a test document in each shortlisted tool: a long-standing client, a supplier, perhaps a relative who seldom uses a computer. Ask them three questions afterwards. Did you understand what you were signing? Was anything confusing? Would you trust the email if it arrived unexpectedly? Their answers often settle a close call.

Keep the test documents realistic but harmless. Use your real layout and wording with invented names and figures, and tell the volunteers it is a trial so nobody mistakes it for a genuine agreement. Void the test envelopes once the scoring is done, so they do not sit in anyone's list looking live.

A worked example

Take a firm of independent financial advisers in Edinburgh, invented for illustration, reviewing its signing tool at renewal. Its paragraph of reasons said that older clients struggled on phones and that compliance staff spent too long finding signed records. Its must list had four items, which cut six names to three. Two advisers scored each tool separately, five clients signed test documents, and the compliance manager timed how long it took to find last month's signed suitability letters. Because the firm advises clients in Scotland, it also asked a Scottish solicitor which of its documents could be signed electronically before relying on any tool for them.

Things to keep, whatever you choose

If you leave any provider, download completed documents and certificates into your own records before the account closes, and keep a note of which tool produced which records and when. Let envelopes in progress finish where they started. That keeps your proof of past agreements independent of any supplier, which is good practice even if you never switch.

A note for firms outside England and Wales

In England and Wales, an electronic signature can be used to sign most documents, as the Law Commission set out in its 2019 report on the electronic execution of documents. Some documents need more: a deed must be signed in the physical presence of a witness, and wills and lasting powers of attorney have their own rules. Check with your adviser which of your documents can be signed electronically.

Scotland and Northern Ireland each have their own rules on how documents are signed, and some documents there need a particular form of signature or witnessing. If a document is governed by the law of either nation, check with a solicitor there, and see our pages on Scotland and Northern Ireland.

Read the individual comparisons

Each page covers a different angle: DocuSign, Adobe Acrobat Sign, Dropbox Sign, PandaDoc and Zoho Sign. To see the full SignAndGo flow, read how it works, or email privacy@myandgo.ai.

Frequently asked questions

How many tools should we trial?
Two or three is usually enough. Use your must list to cut the field before you start, so each trial gets proper attention.
How long should a trial last?
Long enough to send your common documents with real signers and file the results, which for most offices is a few weeks.
What should we keep if we switch?
Every completed document with its certificate, saved into your own records before the old account closes.
Who should test the signing side?
A few real outsiders, such as a long-standing client or supplier, alongside your own staff. They see the tool the way your customers will.

See SignAndGo for your team

Send your first envelope in a few minutes, and keep every signed copy with its audit trail.

See how it works