Choosing an e-signature tool, step by step.
Reading product pages will only take you so far, because every supplier says it is simple and secure. The way to choose well is to test each candidate against your own documents and people, and to ask the same blunt questions of each. This checklist sets out how to do that in a week or two, without turning it into a project.
Step 1: Write down what you sign
Spend twenty minutes listing the documents your business sends for signature. For each one, note who signs it, roughly how often it goes out, whether more than one person signs, and whether anyone internal needs to check it first. Mark anything that is a deed, involves property, or is governed by Scottish or Northern Irish law, and get your adviser's view on those separately.
In England and Wales, an electronic signature can be used to sign most documents, as the Law Commission set out in its 2019 report on the electronic execution of documents. Some documents need more: a deed must be signed in the physical presence of a witness, and wills and lasting powers of attorney have their own rules. Check with your adviser which of your documents can be signed electronically.
Step 2: Turn the list into must-haves
Your list tells you what really matters. Typical must-haves look like this:
- Several signers in a fixed order, with a manager countersigning last.
- Someone in the office approving a document before the client sees it.
- A witness for a small number of documents.
- The same document sent to dozens of people at once.
- Signed copies landing in your accounting system.
- Very long documents, such as a building contract with its drawings.
Separate these from nice-to-haves. A tool that does everything on your nice-to-have list but trips on a must-have is the wrong tool.
Step 3: Shortlist two or three
Do not test ten. Choose two or three tools that appear to cover your must-haves. Our overview of e-signature software for UK businesses introduces the names most UK shortlists include. Check each provider's current plans directly, because published comparisons go out of date.
Step 4: Run the same real test through each
Take one real document, with any personal details removed, and send it through each tool to two colleagues: one comfortable with technology and one who is not. Ask one to sign on a phone and the other on a laptop. Then ask them:
- Was it obvious what the email was and what to do?
- Did you have to create an account or install anything?
- Could you read the document comfortably?
- Was it clear where to sign and what else to fill in?
- Did you get a copy afterwards?
Their answers matter more than yours, because your customers and staff are the ones who will be signing.
Step 5: Inspect what you get back
Open each finished document and look closely. Is there a record of who signed and when? Is it attached to the document itself, or only held in the supplier's system? Can someone outside your business check that the document is genuine? With SignAndGo, the signed PDF has a timestamped audit trail and audit certificate appended, and a verification ID that anyone can check on the public verify page.
Step 6: Ask every supplier the same questions
- How do signers sign, and do they need an account?
- What exactly is recorded for each signature?
- How is witnessing handled, and does that match what our adviser expects?
- How are documents protected, and who in your organisation can see them?
- Can our staff have different roles, and is two-factor authentication available?
- Which of our existing tools does it connect to?
- If we leave, how do we take our signed documents with us?
- How do we get help, and in what form?
For SignAndGo, our features page and security questions guide answer most of these. Documents are kept securely on Google Cloud, encrypted at rest and in transit. Anything not covered can go to privacy@myandgo.ai.
Step 7: Decide, then start small
Score each tool against your must-haves and your colleagues' feedback, and choose. Then move one document type across first, ideally a frequent and simple one, and leave the rest on their current route until that first one runs smoothly. Save it as a template, set automatic reminders, and agree where signed copies are kept.
Mistakes to avoid
- Choosing on the length of a feature list rather than your own documents.
- Testing only on yourself, at your own desk.
- Forgetting to ask how you would get your documents out if you leave.
- Moving deeds or property documents across without your adviser's say-so.
- Rolling out to every team at once.
A worked example
This example is invented for illustration. A recruitment agency in Birmingham lists its documents and finds three must-haves: bulk sending of updated terms to candidates, a consultant approving placement paperwork before it goes out, and signed copies that arrive with a record of who signed and when, ready for the candidate file. It tests two tools with a placement pack sent to a junior colleague on her phone and a director on his laptop, compares the finished files, and asks both suppliers the eight questions above. It chooses, moves candidate terms across first, and adds the placement pack a month later.
Frequently asked questions
- How many tools should we test?
- Two or three is usually enough. Test each with the same real document and the same colleagues so the comparison is fair.
- What is the most overlooked question?
- How you would take your signed documents with you if you stopped using the service.
- Should we move every document at once?
- No. Start with one frequent, simple document type and add others once it runs smoothly. Leave deeds and property documents until your adviser has confirmed the route.
See SignAndGo for your team
Send your first envelope in a few minutes, and keep every signed copy with its audit trail.
See how it works