Digital or electronic signature: are they different?
Ask three people what a digital signature is and you may get three answers. Some use it to mean any signature made on a screen. Others mean a particular piece of cryptography. This article untangles the two terms so you can read a supplier's claims, or a client's request, with a clearer head.
Two words, often swapped
In everyday speech the terms overlap. A letting agent might ask a tenant to 'sign digitally' and mean nothing more than 'sign on your phone'. A software brochure might use 'digital' because it sounds more modern. Neither is wrong in casual use. The trouble starts when one person means the broad idea and the other means the narrow technical one, and both think they are agreeing.
Electronic signature: the broad idea
An electronic signature is the wide category. It is any electronic way of showing that a person agrees to a document: a typed name, a drawn mark, an uploaded image of a signature, or a click on an 'I agree' button. It describes the act of signing, not the technology underneath. Our article on what an electronic signature is covers the forms it takes.
In SignAndGo the signer chooses how to make their mark. They can draw it with a finger or mouse, type their name and have it shown in a handwriting style, or upload an image of their usual signature. Whichever they choose, what makes it a signature is the same: the signer, reached through their own invitation, deliberately completing the document.
Digital signature: usually the technical sense
When an IT team or a security specialist says 'digital signature', they usually mean a cryptographic technique. A mathematical key is used to produce a code tied to the exact contents of a file. If even one character of the file changes, the code no longer matches. Some systems pair this with a certificate that links the key to a named person or organisation.
In that technical sense, a digital signature is a tool for showing that a file has not been altered and for linking it to a key holder. It is one possible ingredient of an electronic signature process, rather than a separate kind of agreement.
A useful way to hold the two apart
- Electronic signature answers the question: did this person agree to this document?
- Digital signature, in the technical sense, answers a narrower question: has this file changed since it was sealed, and which key sealed it?
A business signing an engagement letter mostly cares about the first question, with good enough evidence for the second. That evidence can come from cryptography, from an audit trail, or from both.
Why the picture of a signature is not the point
People sometimes worry that a typed or drawn signature looks less convincing than ink. On its own, the image of a signature proves very little, on screen or on paper: anyone can copy a scanned signature. What gives an electronic signature its weight is the surrounding evidence, such as who the invitation went to, when the document was opened and signed, and whether the file has been altered since. That is also why a scanned signature pasted onto a PDF and emailed is a weak substitute for a proper signing process, whatever it is called.
What evidence a signing service gives you
When you send an envelope through SignAndGo, the signed PDF comes back with a timestamped audit trail and an audit certificate appended to it. The trail records each person who was sent the document and each view and signature with its time. Every signed document also carries a verification ID, and anyone can enter that ID on the public verify page to check the document against our record.
So if a client asks 'is this digitally signed?', it is worth asking what they actually need to know. Usually it is one of these:
- Who signed it, and how do we know it was them?
- When did each person sign?
- Can we tell whether anything was changed after signing?
- Can someone outside the business check it?
The audit trail, the certificate and the verification ID are designed to answer those questions in plain terms. See audit trails explained for what each line of the trail means.
Checking a document someone sends you
The same evidence works when you are on the receiving end. If a supplier or client sends you a PDF they say was signed through SignAndGo, look for the audit certificate at the back of the file and the verification ID. Enter the ID on the public verify page: it shows the document's title, its status, the signers with their email addresses partly hidden, and whether the record checks out. If the page cannot find the ID, ask the sender for the copy they received when signing finished.
When someone insists on a particular method
Occasionally a counterparty, a lender or a public body will ask for a document to be signed in a specific way. When that happens, do not guess from the words they used. Ask them what form they will accept and in what format they need the finished file. Some organisations still want a wet-ink original for certain documents, and that is their call to make.
It also helps to separate a counterparty's preference from what the law requires. In England and Wales, an electronic signature can be used to sign most documents, as the Law Commission set out in its 2019 report on the electronic execution of documents. Some documents need more: a deed must be signed in the physical presence of a witness, and wills and lasting powers of attorney have their own rules. Check with your adviser which of your documents can be signed electronically. Scotland and Northern Ireland each have their own rules, so take advice from a solicitor in that nation if either applies.
Reading supplier claims carefully
Because the terms blur, marketing copy can lean on whichever sounds more impressive. When you compare tools, ask each supplier the same plain questions: what exactly is recorded, how a third party can check a signed document, and what happens to the evidence if you stop using the service. Our guide to choosing an e-signature tool lists the questions worth asking.
Terms worth asking a supplier to explain
- "Tamper-evident". Ask what happens, and what the reader sees, if a signed file is edited afterwards.
- "Bank-grade" or "military-grade". Ask what is actually encrypted, when, and with whose keys.
- "Legally binding". Ask whether they mean every document or most documents, and what they say about deeds and witnessing.
- "Certificate". Ask whether they mean a summary page added to the PDF, a cryptographic certificate, or both.
A good supplier answers these plainly. A vague answer is a useful signal in its own right. And if a supplier cannot tell you how someone outside your business would check a signed document in five years' time, treat that as the most important answer of all.
A quick illustration
Take a small architecture practice in Cardiff, invented for illustration. A client asks for the fee agreement to be 'digitally signed'. The practice manager replies asking what the client's finance team needs. The answer is simply a signed PDF they can keep, showing who signed and when. She sends the agreement as an envelope, the client's director signs in his browser, and the finance team receives the PDF with its audit certificate and verification ID. Nobody needed to debate terminology once the real need was clear.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a digital signature better than an electronic signature?
- They are not really rivals. A digital signature, in the technical sense, is a cryptographic technique that can form part of an electronic signature process. What matters is whether you can show who signed, when, and on which version.
- How can someone check a document signed with SignAndGo?
- Every signed document carries a verification ID. Anyone can enter it on the public verify page to check the document against SignAndGo's record.
- What should I do if a client asks for a specific signing method?
- Ask them what they will accept and in what format. If a particular document has formal requirements, check with your adviser.
- Is a typed signature weaker than a drawn one?
- Not in itself. The image of a signature carries little weight either way. What matters is the record of who was invited, when they opened and signed, and on which version.
See SignAndGo for your team
Send your first envelope in a few minutes, and keep every signed copy with its audit trail.
See how it works