E-signatures and wet-ink signatures, side by side.
A wet signature is the familiar one: pen, paper, a signature line. An e-signature does the same job on a screen. Neither is right for every document. This article compares them honestly, including the cases where printing and signing by hand is still the sensible route.
How each one works in practice
With wet ink, a document is printed, signed by hand, and either handed over, posted or scanned and emailed back. If several people sign, the paper travels between them, or each signs a separate copy and the copies are put together later. The original sits in a filing cabinet.
With an e-signature service, the document is uploaded once and sent as an envelope. Each signer gets a link, signs in a browser, and the service assembles one finished PDF with every signature in place and a record of how it happened.
Speed and the round trip
The main difference most businesses notice is time. A paper contract sent from London to a client in Glasgow depends on the post, on the client having a printer and scanner, and on them remembering to send it back. An envelope can be opened and signed within minutes of arriving, on a phone if that is what the signer has with them.
Multiple signers widen the gap. On paper, a contract needing three signatures in turn can take weeks. With a signing order set on the envelope, each person is invited as soon as the one before has finished, and automatic reminders nudge anyone who has not acted.
Evidence of who signed
A handwritten signature can be compared with other examples of the same person's signature, which is one reason people trust it. But paper records little else. It rarely shows when the signature was made, and a scanned copy shows even less.
An e-signed document from SignAndGo comes with a timestamped audit trail and an audit certificate appended to the PDF, covering who was invited and when each person viewed and signed. Each document also has a verification ID that anyone can check on the public verify page. For a closer look, see audit trails explained.
What each record leaves out
Neither kind of signature proves everything on its own. A handwritten mark on paper does not say whether the signer read every page, whether the pages were swapped afterwards, or when it was signed unless someone wrote the date. An e-signature record shows which email address's link was used, when and in what order, but it cannot show who was holding the device. That is why it matters that each invitation goes to an address the signer alone uses, and why a witness or an in-person meeting still has a place for documents where identity is the main concern.
Mistakes and missing pages
Paper invites small errors: an initial missed on page seven, a date left blank, the wrong version printed. These often surface only when someone needs the document. With e-signing, required fields must be completed before a signer can finish, so the envelope cannot come back half done.
There is a quieter problem with paper too: versions. When a contract is printed, marked up by hand and re-printed, it is easy for two parties to sign slightly different copies without noticing. An envelope sends one file to everybody, and the finished PDF is that same file with every signature added, so there is only ever one version to argue about.
Storage and finding things later
Paper needs space and a filing system, and a document is only as findable as the person who filed it. Signed envelopes stay on your dashboard, and the finished PDF is a normal file you can keep in your own records, alongside the rest of the customer or project file. Documents are kept securely on Google Cloud, encrypted at rest and in transit. Decide on one place for signed copies and keep to it.
A comparison at a glance
- Turnaround: wet ink depends on post or scanning; an e-signature can be done on the day.
- Several signers: wet ink means passing paper around; an envelope invites each person in turn or all at once.
- Record of signing: wet ink records the mark; an e-signature records the mark plus who, when and in what order.
- Errors: wet ink allows missed fields; an envelope can require them.
- Signer effort: wet ink needs a printer and often a scanner; an e-signature needs a browser.
- Retrieval: wet ink needs a filing system; an e-signed PDF is searchable on your dashboard.
What the signer goes through
It is easy to compare the two methods from the sender's side and forget the person on the other end. For a wet-ink signature the signer has to find a printer, print every page, sign and initial in the right places, scan or photograph each page legibly, and email or post it back. Many people stall at the printer.
For an e-signature the signer opens an email, reads the document in their browser, completes the highlighted fields and finishes. There is no account to create and nothing to install. If they have a question, they can ask you before signing, and if they are not willing to sign, they can decline and say why, which you see straight away rather than discovering weeks later that the paper never came back.
When wet ink is still the right choice
E-signing does not suit everything, and it is better to know the exceptions before you start. In England and Wales, an electronic signature can be used to sign most documents, as the Law Commission set out in its 2019 report on the electronic execution of documents. Some documents need more: a deed must be signed in the physical presence of a witness, and wills and lasting powers of attorney have their own rules. Check with your adviser which of your documents can be signed electronically.
Other cases where paper may still be the practical answer:
- A bank, lender or other organisation you deal with asks for a wet-ink original for a particular document. Ask them what they accept.
- A document must be sworn before a solicitor, which needs a different process altogether.
- Some property transfers carry their own formalities. See property documents.
- The document will be signed under Scottish or Northern Irish law, where each nation has its own rules. Check with a solicitor there.
Our page on documents that need more gathers these in one place.
Witnessing is not the same as wet ink
A document that needs a witness does not always need paper, and a document on paper is not automatically witnessed properly. In England and Wales a deed needs a witness physically present when the signer signs. Where your adviser is content for such a document to be signed electronically, the witness still has to be in the room with the signer. Wills and lasting powers of attorney are a separate matter with their own rules. Our page on deeds and witnessing explains more.
A mixed approach is normal
Most businesses end up using both. Consider a firm of chartered surveyors in Leeds, invented for illustration. Its engagement letters, fee agreements and supplier terms all go out as envelopes, and the office no longer chases signed copies. The occasional document a client's lender insists on in ink is still printed. The switch did not need to be all or nothing; it needed a clear list of which documents go which way, agreed with the firm's adviser.
Questions to settle with your adviser
Before you move a type of document from ink to screen, a short conversation with your solicitor or accountant saves second-guessing later. Useful questions to put to them:
- Which of our documents are deeds, and how should each one be signed and witnessed?
- Are any of our documents governed by Scottish or Northern Irish law?
- Do any of the banks, lenders or public bodies we deal with insist on ink for particular documents?
- How long should we keep each kind of signed document, and in what form?
- Is there anything about our sector that changes the answer?
Write the answers down as a short list your whole team can see: which documents go out as envelopes, which are printed, and who to ask about anything new.
Frequently asked questions
- Is an e-signature as good as a handwritten one?
- For most documents in England and Wales an electronic signature can be used, as the Law Commission's 2019 report set out. Deeds, wills and lasting powers of attorney need more. Check with your adviser for your own documents.
- Can I mix wet-ink and e-signed copies?
- Many businesses do, e-signing routine documents and using ink where a counterparty or a formal requirement calls for it.
- Do signers need a printer for e-signing?
- No. They sign in a web browser on a computer, tablet or phone, without an account.
- Does an envelope stop people signing different versions?
- Yes. Every signer is sent the same file, and the finished PDF is that file with all the signatures added, so there is one version rather than several printed copies.
See SignAndGo for your team
Send your first envelope in a few minutes, and keep every signed copy with its audit trail.
See how it works